10 Best Herbalife Alternatives & Competitors (Cheap Substitutes)

January 10, 2024 |

Posted By

Max Health Living is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

Looking for the best and affordable Herbalife alternatives ideal for you?

That’s what this post is all about.

Herbalife Alternative Highlights:
  • PhenQ Meal Shakes: Best meal replacement powder that reduces sugar and fat intake, available in different flavors
  • PhenQ Weight Loss Supplement: Best for fat burn that helps both men and women lose weight rapidly by suppressing food cravings
  • YourBiology Greens: A unique blend of 17 superfoods designed to promote digestion, immunity, energy, and clarity

You know, every person dreams of optimal physical fitness, but they barely have enough time to make their dreams come true.

Our hectic routines leave very little room for focusing on our healthcare needs. Therefore, there has been a sudden surge in the number of meal replacement supplements in the market.

These supplements offer a nutrient-dense answer to your prayers for a healthy meal.

Most of these meal replacement supplements are in protein shakes, and they are extremely easy to make and consume. Herbalife is a similar protein shake that is a healthy meal replacement option.

It has a wide list of natural ingredients, and it comes in 12 different flavors;

However, it contains nine grams of sugar per serving, obviously NOT the best in its class and it’s also not cost-effective.

Fortunately, there are various meal replacement and weight loss supplements on the market today. Better than Herbalife.

And you can choose the best one based on our detailed review.

10 Best Herbalife Alternatives

Here is the list of the best alternatives to Herbalife to consider this year…

#1. PhenQ Meal Shakes

PhenQ shakes flavours

My best, and most affordable product similar to Herbalife is PhenQ meal replacement shakes.

PhenQ shakes is a product that has been created by the Wolfson brand.

If there’s one thing Herbalife is known for: It’s their diet shakes. Their meal replacement shake is called Formula 1. However, there are a few Herbalife nutrition side effects that come with it.

This was one of the reasons why I researched, discovered, and even bought PhenQ meal shakes to try it out myself.

The Wolfson brand is well-known in the world of supplements and offers high-quality products to its users.

The beauty of PhenQ meal replacement powder is its ability to substitute an entire meal while reducing the intake of sugars and fats. Additionally, this meal replacement powder can be purchased in different delicious flavors. All are gluten-free and low-sugar.

PhenQ and Herbalife both have their place in the realm of nutritional supplements, but there are different parameters in which one supplement outshines the other.

Starting with flavor is one of the main factors of a good meal replacement shake.

Herbalife shakes are available for purchase in 12 delicious and amazing flavors, while PhenQ only offers three options, vanilla ice cream, chocolate brownie, and strawberry cream. While the PhenQ shake is delicious, Herbalife wins in the area of flavor due to the increased flavor options.

When comparing the protein content of both of these protein shakes, PhenQ just slightly outshines Herbalife.

Herbalife contains 15 grams of plant proteins in its formulation, while PhenQ shakes contain 16 grams.

PhenQ meal shakes1

Another comparable factor is the source of protein in these shakes. While the protein in Herbalife comes from soy protein, this is not the case for PhenQ.

PhenQ shakes contain plant protein from different sources such as pea protein, hemp protein, and brown rice protein. In this aspect, PhenQ is the better option compared to Herbalife meal shakes.

While the Herbalife protein shake is packed with protein, some other ingredients and nutrients improve a shake’s marketability. PhenQ can do this as it contains a variety of vitamins and minerals, as well as MCT oil, ashwagandha for muscle strength, adaptogens, and omega-3 fatty acids.

Finally, another incredibly important factor in comparing is the price points at which these two shakes are being sold.

Herbalife is sold in 750-gram packaging at the price of $43.3.

At the same time, two 500-gram packets of PhenQ shakes are sold for $39.90. While 3 packets/bags go for $53.85. Which is a nice deal if you ask me.

PhenQ, therefore, is cheaper and offers more bang for your buck when compared to Herbalife.

#2. PhenQ Weight Loss Supplement

PhenQ bottle in garden

Apart from meal replacement shakes – PhenQ also has an amazing product that serves as a pure weight loss alternative to Herbalife Nutrition weight loss products. Called PhenQ appetite suppressant.

You know, Herbalife’s weight loss program includes protein shakes, weight loss supplements, and teas. In order to “induce weight loss”, Herbalife substitutes certain meals with its own meal-replacement protein shakes and other supplements.

While some people may benefit from using Herbalife weight loss products – in my opinion – it is not the best for an effective and long-term weight loss goal.

PhenQ weight loss pills on the other hand help both men and women lose weight rapidly by suppressing their food cravings.

There are a few reasons an appetite suppressant can be an important tool for weight loss.

First, when you’re trying to lose weight, it’s important to create a calorie deficit—that is, consume fewer calories than you expend. An appetite suppressant can help make creating this deficit a bit easier by reducing your hunger and cravings.

Second, if you’re like most people, you may find it difficult to stick to a very restrictive diet for long periods of time. An appetite suppressant can help make this easier by reducing the temptation to overeat.

Finally, some research suggests that certain appetite suppressants may help increase the amount of fat burned by the body. All of these factors can contribute to successful weight loss

Natural appetite suppressant like PhenQ is way better than Herbalife for weight loss because they work by controlling the amount of hunger that you feel. This means that you will be less likely to snack or overeat, which can lead to significant weight loss over time.

No doubt, Herbalife can help you lose some weight, but it is not as effective at controlling hunger as appetite suppressants are.

Other benefits of using the PhenQ weight loss pill include:

  • No prescription required
  • Helps to burn excess fat
  • Reduce cravings for sweets and carbs
  • Promote a feeling of fullness
  • Boosts mental and body energy
  • No side effects and suitable for both men and women

One bottle of PhenQ weight loss supplement costs $69.99. When you order 3 bottles you get it at the price of 2. Basically, the more PhenQ you ORDER, the more discount applies.

#3. YourBiology Greens Powder

YourBiology Supergreens

Looking for a Herbalife alternative that can help you achieve optimal physical fitness and health goals? Look no further than YourBiology Greens.

This unique blend of 17 superfoods is designed to help you reboot digestion, reignite radiance, revive immunity, replenish energy, and recover clarity.

Unlike Herbalife, YourBiology Greens is free from artificial additives and contains no added sugars. It’s packed with vitamins, minerals, amino acids, flavonoids, polyphenols, antioxidants, fatty acids, and trace elements. It’s also vegan-friendly and 100% clean.

YourBiology Greens is easy to use and tastes great. Simply mix it with water or your favorite beverage, and you’ve got a powerhouse of nutrients ready to amp up your health in a jiffy.

With YourBiology Greens, you’ll enjoy serene digestion, vibrant immunity, effervescent energy, unwavering focus, sunny vibes, and a luminous glow. It’s the perfect Herbalife alternative for those looking for a clean, nutrient-dense meal replacement option.

YourBiology Greens offers two purchasing options. A single purchase for $69.99 provides a 30-day supply at only $2.33 per serving.

The subscribe & save option offers a 25% discount, providing one bottle per month at only $52.49, which equates to only $1.75 per serving. This option is the most popular and has no commitment; you can cancel anytime.

And if you’re not completely satisfied, they also offer a 60-day hassle-free money-back guarantee.

#4. Shakeology


Shakeology® is a nutritional, meal-replacement shake that provides full nutrition to the body.

With over 15 different superfoods that are all selected for their specific health benefits, they offer everything you need for energy and protection from free radicals to dietary support for higher fitness performance.

Shakeology is another protein-rich meal replacement supplement that serves as a perfect Herbalife alternative.

However, it’s better than Herbalife due to its superior ingredient list. Shakeology contains various beneficial ingredients such as antioxidants that combat free radicals and prevent all sorts of inflammatory reactions in your body.

This best Herbalife alternative also consists of nutrient-dense super-fruits loaded with antioxidants such as goji berries, acerola cherries, bilberry, and camu camu.

It’s also enriched with the goodness of prebiotics and probiotics that promote healthy gut bacteria formation.

Shakeology also contains Adaptogens which are stress-reducing herbs. It also consists of phytonutrients that reduce inflammation. Furthermore, Shakeology has greater benefits than Herbalife.

The high protein content in Shakeology helps with weight loss and helps with muscle mass development. It boosts optimal energy levels, and reduces inflammation and stress, along with giving you a healthy gut.

While a product similar to Herbalife like Shakeology contains a better ingredient list and more benefits, it costs more than Herbalife Nutrition.

Shakeology is available for $129.5, which is the price of a single bag containing thirty servings.

The product is also available in different flavors, and you can also opt for combo boxes that come with 24 single-serving packs in multiple flavors.

Therefore, it’s safe to say that Herbalife is more cost-effective than Shakeology.

Related: Herbalife vs. Shakeology: Which is Better?

#5. 310 Shake

310 shake

310 Shake is a supplement produced by the brand 310 Nutrition.

It’s a nutrient-dense meal replacement shake with a high protein and low-carb formula. The high protein and carb concentration in this shake increases your satiety levels and keeps you feeling full for an extended period.

It also boosts your metabolism for effective weight loss.

While 310 shakes also offer a huge variety of flavors, they are still less than the 12 flavors offered by Herbalife.

310 shakes are available in 9 flavors.

However, they are still better than Herbalife products because they don’t contain processed sugar. The 310 shakes have less sugar than Herbalife shakes, and the sugar used in 310 products is obtained from plant sources, and they offer zero calories.

The 310 shakes also stand out compared to the Herbalife supplement due to its gluten-free and vegan formula.

This shake also contains more beneficial ingredients than Herbalife. Some of these ingredients include 15 grams of pure whey protein, various antioxidants, zero artificial sugars, and probiotics.

Moreover, these shakes come in different price packages.

You can purchase 14 servings of the 310 shakes for $39, or you can buy 28 servings for $68. At the same time, this brand does offer more price options compared to Herbalife, its single-serving costs more than Herbalife.

#6. Exante Diet


Exante Diet is a brand that is famous for its innovation in meal replacement products.

This brand offers meal-replacement juices, meal-replacement shakes, and meal-replacement bars. Furthermore, it contains a greater variety of ingredients as opposed to Herbalife.

The Exante Diet meal replacement shakes are rich in high-quality protein and twenty-seven minerals and vitamins, which is more than the nutrient content of Herbalife.

Furthermore, these supplements are available in more flavors than Herbalife.

Their exquisite taste satisfies all your sugar cravings by catering to your sweet tooth. It also comes in tangy flavors such as pomegranate, grapefruit, peach, mango, and apple.  Furthermore, these supplements are a rich source of fiber that promotes gut health and improves your metabolism by enhancing the process of digestion.

Their high whey protein content makes them ideal for losing weight. Anyone can also consume these supplements following a very low-calorie diet.

The Exante Diet products are also low in sugar, but their flavors are still effective for dealing with your sugar cravings.

These products are available in pounds, and different products have different prices.

Their shakes, juices, and bars have different prices. However, all their products are within the range of 20 pounds. Therefore, their prices are slightly higher compared to the Herbalife supplements.

Furthermore, the brand keeps offering regular discount promos and codes to be used by everyone.

They also offer their products in various cost-effective and health-promoting bundles.

#7. Isagenix


Another brand that produces shakes similar to that of Herbalife is Isagenix – a popular brand that offers a vast range of meal replacement supplements, and personal care products with a multi-level marketing system.

These supplements are a rich source of high-quality protein. These supplements are better than Herbalife because they offer 24 grams of protein per serving which is greater than the amount of protein offered by Herbalife.

It also contains essential branched chained amino acids such as leucine, isoleucine, and valine.

These amino acids are called essential amino acids because our body can’t make them on its own, and they have to be consumed from external sources.

These meal replacement supplements stay true to their name, and they contain a nutrient-dense formula with ample carbohydrate and protein content.

Carbs are the primary source of energy for our bodies. Therefore, the high carb content in these supplements keeps you energized at all times.

Furthermore, these shakes don’t contain any type of empty calories.

They are also enriched with 23 different vitamins and minerals, and they are available in numerous tasty flavors. People with different allergies can consume these products since they are gluten-free and soy-free.

Isagenix’s price range is $41.99 per canister and $44.99 per packet. The Isagenix supplements might cost a bit more than Herbalife products, but they have a better formulation and more health benefits than Herbalife.

#8. Soylent


As the name suggests, Soylent supplements revolve around soy protein, making its ingredient list superior to Herbalife. Which makes it a perfect Herbalife alternative.

They contain plant-based soy protein famous for containing all the essential amino acids.

It is also equipped with the goodness of 28 vitamins and minerals.

The Soylent supplements are one of a kind and better than Herbalife supplements due to their unique and highly beneficial ingredient list.

These supplements consist of various healthy fats such as omega-3 fatty acids and omega-6 fatty acids.

These fats ensure optimal hormone production and keep you energized.

These products are also an excellent source of complex carbohydrates that take more time to digest and keep you fuller for a longer time, leading to effective weight loss.

These supplements are true meal replacement products due to their extensive macronutrient content.

Furthermore, they are available in various delicious flavors made using natural sugars. The sugar product used in these supplements is known as allulose.

Allulose is a type of carbohydrate that contains very few calories. Furthermore, it has a low glycemic index which keeps you safe from sudden blood sugar spikes.

All Soylent products are free from lactose, and they don’t contain any dairy.

The Soylent protein meal replacement drinks are available for $42 per 12 bottles, which is almost similar to the Herbalife price range.

Additionally, these products are available in meal replacement drinks, powder, and bars.

#9. SlimFast


The last meal shake replacement on our best Herbalife competitors and alternatives is SlimFast.

SlimFast is a brand that has the answer to all your health complications.

They offer a wide range of meal replacement supplements suited to individual needs. Their meal replacement supplements are available in energy drinks, bars, and powdered forms.

Furthermore, they have different products for people following a low-carb diet.

They have a separate range for the keto diet followers.

They also have an advanced energy range for individuals experiencing low energy levels, and one of their finest inventions is their range of diabetic weight loss supplements.

Their products contain up to 23 different minerals and vitamins. They are available in different sweet flavors, but they don’t contain any synthetic sugar.

These products are also free from preservatives, artificial flavors, or colors.

All their products offer around 200 calories per serving, and they offer a nutrient-dense and effective solution to retain optimal weight loss. However, the nutrient content of Herbalife is better than these supplements.

SlimFast products are available in various affordable price ranges and packages.

You could purchase a 12.83oz canister for just $9.99, or go for the 20.18oz canister for $12.99. You could also get a three-pack 12.93oz canister for $26.97 or a three-pack 20.18oz canister for $35.97.

Therefore, these products are more affordable and cost-effective compared to Herbalife.

#10. XYZ Smart Collagen

XYZ Collagen pack

As you may know, Herbalife also has a line of beauty products that claim to help you look and feel younger, and they have a range of different formulations for different skin types. Herbalife also offers a range of makeup items, including foundation, blush, bronzer, and mascara.

From my experience and research, overall, the reviews for Herbalife’s beauty products are mixed.

Some people love them and find that they’ve made a noticeable difference in the appearance of their skin, while others say that the products didn’t do anything for them.

This is where the XYZ Smart Collagen comes in. An effective and much cheaper substitute for Herbalife beauty products.

The reason why XYZ Smart Collagen is a better alternative to Herbalife beauty products is that the cream makes you look 7.5 years younger. This beauty solution for young and aged ladies has been clinically proven and tested on real women.

This “smart collagen” cream is dermatologist-approved and delivers outstanding visible results in just 12 weeks.

While Herbalife beauty and skin care products are designed to help improve the appearance of your skin by moisturizing it, cleansing it, and protecting it from the sun – they tend to offer a different range of products that seem expensive.

That’s not the case with XYZ smart collagen.

Furthermore, it also works on improving your skin’s natural production of collagen which as we age, wrinkles start to form and our skin starts to sag. The active ingredient in this beauty formula is derived from the leaf sap of Bulbine frutescens, a native plant of South Africa.

Scientific studies have shown that this sap contains two powerful compounds that slow collagen breakdown in the dermis and increase collagen production – without triggering the body’s immune system, which would interfere with the process and cause low-quality collagen to build up in the body.

Other benefits of this Herbalife replacement include:

  • Reduces wrinkles
  • Lifts & contours
  • Tightens & firms
  • Improves skin texture
  • Reduces stretch marks

The cost of XYZ collagen goes to $49.9 for a pack. If you buy more than 1 pack, you get 1 pack for free. Plus, a free delivery.

Other Products similar to Herbalife include:

  • Premier Protein
  • Shaklee
  • Modere
  • 1st phorm
  • Arbonne
  • Usana
  • Advocare
  • Atkins
  • Ensure

Final Thoughts: Which is the best alternative?

If you want to find the best Herbalife alternative, there are a few things that can help.

You should look for an organic supplement that is made from all-natural ingredients and has been clinically proven to work as well as other popular diet pills on the market. We have found some great products in our research here.

For example, PhenQ appetite suppressant:

PhenQ is a natural appetite suppressant that has been formulated with 100% natural ingredients. These ingredients have been scientifically proven to be effective in suppressing appetite and helping people to lose weight. Additionally, PhenQ is backed by a team of experts who have years of experience in the health and fitness industry.

With all of these factors, you can be assured that PhenQ is a safe and effective option for suppressing your appetite and helping you to lose weight.

Also, meal replacement supplements are all the rage these days due to their nutrient-dense content and convenient usage.

Therefore, the market has become saturated with various meal replacement supplements.

While all supplements have their pros and cons, you need to make sure that you’ve set your priorities straight before purchasing any product.

It’s also important to remember that you must never compromise on the supplements’ quality or ingredient list.

Based on the list mentioned above of meal supplements, the best one I would highly recommend is PhenQ Shakes, and Soylent due to their high nutrient concentration and affordable prices. That is if you’re looking for a safer replacement for Herbalife meal shakes.

That said, your choice ultimately depends on your nutritional preferences, fitness needs, and budget.

All of the Herbalife alternatives on this list are awesome meal replacements in their own ways.

Important Disclaimer: The information contained on MAX HEALTH LIVING is intended for informational and educational purposes only. Any statements made on this website have not been evaluated by the FDA and any information or products discussed are not intended to diagnose, cure, treat, or prevent any disease or illness. Please consult a healthcare practitioner before making changes to your diet or taking supplements that may interfere with medications.

Who We Are

We are a team of fitness, health, and supplement experts, and content creators. Over the past 4 years, we have spent over 123,000 hours researching food supplements, meal shakes, weight loss, and healthy living. Our aim is to educate people about their effects, benefits, and how to achieve a maximum healthy lifestyle. Read more.