Herbalife vs Slimfast: Which one is Better?

January 7, 2024 |

Posted By

Max Health Living is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

Slimfast and Herbalife are two of the most popular dieting products on the market.

It’s a close call as to which one is better, but there are some differences between them that make it hard to compare them.

In this article, I’m going to compare the two nutritional supplement manufacturing giants formulating nutrient-rich efficacious products for decades.

So, if until now, you have been confused about which company to prefer for achieving your desired weight goals, consider your ambiguities cleared already since I’ll be discussing all the nitty-gritty details here elaborately.

Since we all are well aware that everyone’s built differently, it’s needless to say that not every product turns out to work wonders for everyone, which eventually means that to make something suit your well, understanding the needs and working of the products as well as your body is mandatory.

This is why I have covered all important aspects of Herbalife and Slimfast’s weight loss products here so that you know beforehand if it’s worth spending your hard-earned money or not.

From benefits to side effects, cost, ingredients, and customer feedback, I have covered it all here for both brands.

So, without any further delay, let’s get right into it.

Herbalife and Slimfast – A Brief Rundown

Before diving into the detailed comparisons of both the companies, let’s have a quick overview of what these two are really about!

What is Herbalife?

Herbalife has been in the nutrition and health industry for a little over 40 years and has gained hundreds of thousands of customers during this period.

Effective fitness products and excellent dietary plans have led the company to be one of the most liked and popular nutrition brands in the market.

From meal replacing shakes and dietary supplements to beauty and skincare products, Herbalife exhibits a wide variety of creations. You name it; they have it!

Moreover, the brand has expertise in providing you with customized diet plans that go well with your fitness and wellness goals without you having to worry about disrupting the natural body balance.

Initially found in Los Angeles, Herbalife has now paved its way to more than 90 countries worldwide.

The reason for its success?

Careful plantation and conservation of resources to bring forward the best of nature’s reserves to you!

What is Slimfast?

Slimfast logo

The second brand that I am going to give a brief introduction to is Slimfast.

If you are a foodie and cannot suppress cravings for scrumptious food items but still want to lose those extra pounds, this is the company for you.

The brand focuses on targeting certain areas of your weight loss journey that prove to be successful and do not have you compromise on your cravings.

This might seem like a far-fetched idea, but it is true!

You will come across a variety of smoothies, shakes, and bars with all the nutrients you need without encouraging fat accumulation.

Small, nutritious portions that are ready to eat are also available, making the process hassle-free.

There is a complete range of products, from ketogenic staples to a variety of shake mixes that can be customized according to your fitness goals.

You are advised to practice physical activity along with the diet plans, which eventually escalates your journey towards a fit life.

Herbalife vs Slimfast – Which One Is Better?

Now that we have two renowned fitness brands on the table for us, the question arises as to which of these two is more efficacious, worth spending money on.

I have listed down all the pointers from my research into brief categories to help you find the answers you are looking for.

1. Efficacy

Herbalife: All the products that you see in Herbalife’s product range are so far quite effective and quick to act.

The best part about the meal replacing shakes is that they are packed with all the desired nutrients, including proteins, without exceeding your calories intake limit.

With these shakes, you get fuller in no time, which results in decreased appetite and diminished intake of junk food.

Every formula is hassle-free to consume, so say goodbye to the complicated dietary meals!

Slimfast: The company has been providing meal-replacing protein shakes for quick weight loss since 1977.

The brand has a unique approach to help people achieve their fitness goals by eating one meal of their choice and replacing the other two with their shakes.

It is more about satisfying your cravings without strict diet control. This sounds fun and pretty easy to do!

Final Verdict: In my opinion, Herbalife has a more professional approach towards fitness goals.

The process is not hasty and takes a lot of patience but proves to be fruitful in the long run.

2. Side Effects

Herbalife: The products, however, deemed safe, are not suitable to use for everyone.

People with kidney and liver problems need to consult with their physician first before going for Herbalife’s dietary programs and products.

The products have high sugar content, which holds them unsuitable for diabetics or the ones at the risk of developing diabetes.

You should go for a trial first as you might experience headaches, vomiting, stomach upsets, diarrhea, and other similar side effects, for starters.

Slimfast: No serious side effects have been reported regarding Slimfast products except for little stomach upsets, headache, and bloating.

People with underlying medical conditions need to consult their doctors before they consume these products to avoid undesirable results.

Final Verdict: Despite being safe companies for many people out there, both Herbalife and Slimfast come with minor adverse effects that may become serious threats for patients with certain medical conditions.

It is always best to consult with your physicians for better guidance regarding the use of these meal replacement shakes and snacks.

3. Herbalife and Slimfast Cost

Herbalife: Herbalife is an expensive brand with all the products ranging from $40 to a little above $130.

The diet plans and programs have different rates according to customization and portion control.

Slimfast: The products by Slimfast are cheaper as compared to those of Herbalife. The shake mixes, shakes, and low-calorie snacks – all fall in an affordable range that is accessible to all.

Final Verdict: If I need to name the cheaper one, it will be Slimfast. Herbalife products are affordable too but not more than the latter.

This makes Slimfast’s dietary plans and programs convenient to follow for those who are on a budget.

4. Taste

Herbalife: The meals replacement shakes are powdery in texture and require a blender to properly blend the shake mixes with skimmed milk. The taste, however, is less sweet and feels ‘synthetic’.

Slimfast: Its shakes and snacks are sweeter with a fluffy texture when mixed properly.

You do not require a blender or shaker to do so since the mixes are already finely ground.

Final Verdict: As far as taste and texture are concerned, I am going to vote for Slimfast.

Its meal replacement shakes are easier to consume because of their good, smooth and creamy texture and sweet taste.

5. Product Range

Herbalife: Herbalife is a multipurpose company with a variety of products under one roof. You get to see weight loss and fitness products as well as a dynamic skincare range here.

Its meal replacement shakes, and protein formula powders are the best out there and complimented by many.

On the other hand, the skincare and acne solution range, including soaps, bars, and skincare essentials, has also earned compliments worldwide.

It has an edge here because of the diversity in its products!

Slimfast: Slimfast presents to you its flagship products like meal replacement shakes and protein snacks that help you keep full for most of the day.

The low-calorie snacks and meal replacement bars are other products that the brand has to offer to you! So Slimfast is more about shakes and bars for consumption.

Final Verdict: Herbalife is characterized by a diversity of products, including those for ingestion as well as a topical application for optimal skincare, so it is an all-in-one haven for fitness and health enthusiasts.

Slimfast, on the other hand, is more about protein shakes and low-calorie snacks, which are all to be consumed, so the former has the edge here!

6. Ingredients

Herbalife: The ingredients that we get to see in Herbalife’s products are oats, wheat, protein extracts, and essential vitamins.

Their meal replacement shakes are synthesized, keeping in mind your daily dietary requirements, so that without lowering your energy levels, you may shed the unwanted calories!

Energy drinks like caffeine beverages and others with aloe vera extract keep you fresh and hydrated all day long.

Slimfast: The renowned products by Slimfast are its shakes which contain a handful of required proteins and other nutrients.

This is to ensure that if you are skipping your meals and consuming these instead, you do not miss important nutrients.

Emulsifiers and stabilizers have been added to give the shakes their texture and flavor so that they are not bland to consume.

The little treats have soy, wheat, and oats, whereas others are power-packed with vitamins, fruit bits, and green tea extract to make your meals less boring.

Final Verdict: Both the companies have beneficial ingredients in their products that help you fulfill your dietary needs without having to compromise on nutrition.

Herbalife and Slimfast – Best Products

Both fitness companies have a wide variety of products that fasten your weight loss journey and help you achieve your fitness goals.

Here, I am going to review some of their best products that not only gained popularity within no time but also are said to be unquestionably efficacious!


  • Herbalife Formula 1 Shake


The first product that I am going to talk about is Herbalife’s Formula 1 Shake which is renowned for its high-quality ingredients that support your journey towards a healthier and fitter life.

It is a plant-based meal replacement shake that is created after an in-depth analysis of the right type and amount of ingredients. Soy and wheat isolates found in it are derived from organic sources to make the product worthwhile.

What are the constituents exactly?

Antioxidants, vitamins, and wheat are the principal ones that are almost equivalent to eating healthy veggies like broccoli and nuts like almonds which makes the product an all-in-one formula!

Moreover, this product can be consumed conveniently since all you need to do is blend it with skimmed milk.

You can even add fruits, vegetables, and nuts according to your preferences and portion control.

With a variety of different tasty flavors, Herbalife Formula 1 Shake is one of the best meal replacement options out there for all of you fitness enthusiasts!

  • Herbalife Afresh Energy Drink Mix


The second popular product by Herbalife is its Afresh Energy Drink Mix which is yet another incredible derivative that came into being after well-researched sourcing of plant products from all over the world.

As the name indicates, the drink is supposed to keep you energized all day long without you having to compromise your diet. This is executed by packing it with rejuvenating ingredients like green tea extract, orange pekoe extract as well as natural caffeine powder.

You can mix a spoonful of the powder with hot or cold water and consume the drink not more than thrice a day.

You may also gradually eliminate excessive tea and coffee intake from your life by incorporating this energy drink into your diet.

Many happy customers have reported noticing a significant weight loss after consuming this energy drink for quite some time since it prevents them from snacking on junk food.

Even though it is a safe, over-the-counter product, you still need to consult your physician before regularly consuming it.

I suggest going for a trial too, to avoid adverse side effects.


  • Slimfast Shakes


Slimfast is renowned for its shakes that can help you fulfill the protein and carbohydrate deficit in the body which results when you skip your regular meals.

The enhanced formula now has more protein and fewer carbs to correct the high sugar intake.

Other ingredients include fructose, maltodextrin, carrageenan, and essential vitamins, which keep you fresh and fit all day long.

The best part about Slimfast Shakes and smoothies is how they are convenient to consume.

The shake mixes are easy to blend and do not require a shaker or blender. The end product is a fluffy mixture of all the nutrients that otherwise you would have to consume by eating a lot of veggies and fruits.

Please note that these shakes, though full of desired nutrients, do not substitute the healthier, homemade smoothies.

Last but not least, artificial sweeteners are present in the shakes, which might be a potential risk factor for diabetics.

  • Slimfast Keto Fat Bomb Meal Bars


Coming to these miraculous meal bars, I have to mention how effective and fulfilling these snacks by Slimfast are.

Now you do not need to worry about compiling and making a complete ketogenic meal every time, as you can simply go for this power-packed bar instead.

These meal bars are characterized by low carbohydrates and a variety of minerals and vitamins.

All the nutrients are present on accurate ratios to provide you with all their goodness but without you having to put on extra weight!

The meal bars are free from artificial sweeteners and colors and perfectly complement your keto macros.

You can take along these delicious bites wherever you go, which cuts down the hassle of cooking proper meals – all the more reason for you to get it!

FAQs on Herbalife vs Slimfast

Is Slimfast a good way to lose weight?

As much as the shakes and meal bars contain all the necessary ingredients and nutrition to help you in your weight loss journey, these still are not comparable to other healthier options like homemade smoothies.

You can go for a quick weight loss program, but if you have time and patience, I suggest going for the healthier ways instead.

Is Slimfast as good as Herbalife?

Both the fitness companies come with their pros and cons.

Herbalife is on the expensive side as compared to Slimfast but has a more professional approach towards weight loss, whereas Slimfast has tastier shakes and snacks in an affordable price range but might not prove to be good in the long run.

Is Slimfast better than Herbalife?

In terms of taste and texture, it is better than Herbalife. But as far as weight loss goals are concerned, both the brands have pretty much the same nutrition regimen as well as additives and side effects.

How much weight can you lose just by drinking Slimfast?

Slimfast shakes are of no significant value in your weight loss journey and fitness goals until and unless you cut down on excess carbs in your diet too.

Customized diet plans and programs are given to individuals according to their body and weight loss goals which include portion control and exercise in addition to shakes and supplements.

This is how you will eventually see results.

When will I see results from Slimfast?

If you follow the diet plan accurately along with adequate physical activity and portion control, you will begin to see results in 3 to 4 weeks.

Is Herbalife the best way to lose weight?

Not really.

The only best way to lose weight is by eating healthy cutting down on carbs and fats and engaging yourself in daily exercise.

If you want to go for a foolproof, quick path to fitness, Herbalife might work for you but keep in mind that it comes with its share of cons.

Final Thoughts

You must have realized by now how both the fitness companies Herbalife and Slimfast come with a variety of products that aid weight loss by their nutrition-filled, effective formulas.

Herbalife with its formula 1 shakes and shake mixes and Slimfast with meal replacement protein shakes and low-calorie snacks – both help you cut down on high-calorie carbs and fats by satisfying your cravings and decreasing appetite.

However, don’t forget to consult your physician before using the products, and you are good to go!

Lastly, remember that every convenience comes with a price.

You can go for these quick fitness escapes but keep in mind that they can never be as good as other healthy options like following a calorie-restricted diet and following a healthy lifestyle.

Important Disclaimer: The information contained on MAX HEALTH LIVING is intended for informational and educational purposes only. Any statements made on this website have not been evaluated by the FDA and any information or products discussed are not intended to diagnose, cure, treat, or prevent any disease or illness. Please consult a healthcare practitioner before making changes to your diet or taking supplements that may interfere with medications.

Who We Are

We are a team of fitness, health, and supplement experts, and content creators. Over the past 4 years, we have spent over 123,000 hours researching food supplements, meal shakes, weight loss, and healthy living. Our aim is to educate people about their effects, benefits, and how to achieve a maximum healthy lifestyle. Read more.