11 Best Isagenix Alternatives & Competitors: Which is Better?

January 9, 2024 |

Posted By

Max Health Living is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

This is an in-depth review of better Isagenix alternatives in the market today.

But before we proceed – let me as you a question.

Who doesn’t want a perfect fit physique?

While our diet has a 70% contribution to our physical fitness, exercise offers a 30% contribution. However, sometimes our body needs an extra nudge to help us attain our goals.

Fitness supplements are the best candidate for this external nudge.

Isagenix is a brand dedicated to offering the finest high-quality protein-rich meal replacement supplements that are available in the form of bars, shakes, and beverages.

This brand also has its very own range of detoxifying, cleansing, and skin health-promoting supplements.

However, its limited ingredient list and high sugar content make one wonder if there are any healthier alternatives to Isagenix. Fortunately, there are numerous supplements in the market today which makes it difficult to choose the best option for us.

Keep reading to go through a comparative review to learn about our favorite brands and products similar to Isagenix that suits your need.

Summary: Best Isagenix Alternatives (audience-based product appeal)

  1. PhenQ meal shakes: Best for shakes and weight loss
  2. PhenQ weight loss pills: instant weight loss solution
  3. Instant Knockout Complete: Most delicious for fighters
  4. XYZ Collagen: best Isagenix collagen elixir alternative
  5. Herbalife: Best for people with poor gut health
  6. Exante Diet: Best for Anemics
  7. Optivia: Best for people who want healthy snacks
  8. 310 Shakes: Best for people on a tight budget
  9. Huel: Best for people with a knack for savory products
  10. SlimFast: Best for diabetics
  11. Soylent: Best for people with lactose intolerance

Let’s get into full detail about all the above competitors:

#1. PhenQ Meal replacement

PhenQ shakes flavours

It is safe to say that PhenQ complete meal shakes is similar (and a better replacement) to the IsaLean™ meal replacements by Isagenix.

Wolfson brand – the company behind PhenQ – is a company that has been a part of the supplement market for a long time.

They have created numerous successful and trusted supplements; among these is the PhenQ weight loss brand.

And one of their top products is the PhenQ meal replacement protein shakes.

PhenQ shakes is a vegan-friendly meal replacement shake that is made completely of plant-based ingredients. It may be used to substitute a meal during a hectic day without sacrificing important nutrients.

PhenQ vs Isagenix

Both Isagenix and PhenQ are nutritiously packed protein shakes that can be used to replace meals. When comparing both shakes, you can see which aspect of each shake is better than the other.

Isagenix has a whopping 24 grams of protein, while PhenQ only contains 16 grams of plant proteins.

However, PhenQ outshines Isagenix when it comes to the overall ingredient list. PhenQ contains 24 vitamins and minerals, adaptogens, MCT oil, and Innoslim.

In terms of flavor profile, Isagenix provides its customers with six different options. In comparison, PhenQ is only available in two flavors, chocolate, and vanilla. This makes Isagenix a better option when considering flavors.

The final comparison point of these two protein shakes is their cost. The PhenQ meal replacement shake is sold according to grams and costs a total of $39.90 for two packets (500 grams each). Isagenix, however, is sold in terms of pounds, and their prices begin at $55.99.

==> Check out PhenQ shakes here

#2. PhenQ weight loss pill

PhenQ bottle tablet

PhenQ is an appetite suppressant made by the same company above. This is a weight loss supplement that helps people lose weight, increase their energy levels, and burn fat naturally.

As you already know – apart from the meal shakes – Isagenix offers a range of weight management products like the:

  • 30-Day Weight Loss System
  • 9-Day Nutritional Cleansing System
  • And many more

Despite some users benefiting from Herbalife weight loss products, in my opinion, Herbalife products are not the best for long-term weight management.

On the other hand, PhenQ weight loss pills suppress hunger cravings for both men and women to help them lose weight quickly.

I’ve done a ton of research, and I’ve also discovered that Isagenix could be harmful to some people. I mean there are side effects that come with some of their products. This is where PhenQ appetite suppressant comes in as a safer (and cheaper alternative).

PhenQ is made of natural ingredients and does not have any harmful side effects like Isagenix products.

Isagenix products are known to cause various side effects such as nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, risk of heart problems, headaches, cramps, etc.

It’s not just about the health problems associated with Isagenix. In my experience, an appetite suppressant like PhenQ is way better for weight loss.

For one, it helps you eat fewer calories: Appetite suppressants work by reducing your hunger and making you feel fuller for longer. This means that you will naturally eat fewer calories throughout the day, which can lead to weight loss.

Some studies have shown that appetite suppressants can reduce calorie intake by up to 25%. This can be a significant difference, especially if you are struggling to lose weight.

Appetite suppressants can also work by increasing the level of satiety hormones in your body. These hormones signal to your brain that you are full and do not need to eat.

Some appetite suppressants work by affecting the way that food is absorbed in your body.

For example, some appetite suppressants can delay stomach emptying. This means that you will feel full for longer after eating and will not be as likely to snack between meals. All of these mechanisms work together to help reduce your hunger and make it easier for you to eat fewer calories.

Other benefits of using the PhenQ weight loss pill include:

  • No prescription required
  • Helps to burn excess fat
  • Reduce cravings for sweets and carbs
  • Promote a feeling of fullness
  • Boosts mental and body energy
  • No side effects and suitable for both men and women

One bottle of PhenQ weight loss supplement costs $69.99. When you order 3 bottles you get it at the price of 2. Basically, the more PhenQ you purchase, the more discount applies.

[su_button url=”https://maxhealthliving.com/phenq” target=”blank” background=”#FF0075″ size=”10″ center=”yes” icon=”icon: arrow-right”]ORDER PHENQ TO GET 1 FREE[/su_button]

#3. Instant Knockout Complete shakes

Instant knockout shakes

I recently discovered the Instant Knockout complete meal replacement shakes – one of the best-selling products by Roar Ambition. A brand that manufactures shakes similar to Isagenix.

If you looking for a way to maintain your muscle mass while losing weight at the same time, then Instant Knockout Complete is the best alternative in this regard.

They provide a formula that is high in protein (35g), high in fiber (25g), and helps you reduce weight while retaining muscle mass. Because it is made with slow-burning carbs, it will keep you full for hours.

Some of the ingredients that make up Instant knockout shakes are:

Pea Protein, Soy Protein Isolate, MCT (from Coconut), Brown Rice Protein, Vitamin & Mineral Blend, Chia Seed Powder, Xanthan Gum, Sucralose, Rice Hull Concentrate, Oat Flour, Pea Starch, Golden Flaxseed Powder, Natural Flavour, Bacillus Coagulans, Lactobacillus Casei.

27 micronutrients are included in Instant Knockout, the majority of which are 30% or more of your daily requirements.

The first thing that you’ll notice about the Instant Knockout Complete shake is that it contains a blend of protein, carbohydrates, and healthy fats.

This unique blend of nutrients helps to keep you feeling full and satisfied after your meal, so you’re less likely to snack or overeat later on. The shake also contains a range of vitamins and minerals that help to support your overall health.

There are three options for purchasing Instant Knockout Complete meal shakes:

You can either purchase one pouch, which contains 14 meals, for $59, purchase two pouches (28 meals) for $118, or 56 meals (lasts 2 months) for $236.

[su_button url=”https://maxhealthliving.com/instantshakes” target=”blank” background=”#FF0075″ size=”10″ center=”yes” icon=”icon: arrow-right”]BUY INSTANT COMPLETE SHAKES[/su_button]

#4. XYZ Smart Collagen

XYZ Collagen pack

As we age, our bodies produce less and less collagen. This contributes to wrinkles, saggy skin, and other signs of aging. Isagenix range of natural beauty products and collections is a line of skincare and haircare products that are formulated to nourish and protect the skin and hair.

After some research, I couldn’t really find many bad sides about their beauty collection. Besides the cost. Could be expensive in my opinion.

This is where the XYZ Smart Collagen serves as an alternative – especially to the popular Isagenix Collagen Elixir.

The reason XYZ Smart Collagen is superior to Isagenix beauty products is that it makes you look 7.5 years younger. Women of all ages will benefit from this beauty solution that has been clinically proven and tested.

Within 12 weeks, you are going to see outstanding results from this dermatologist-approved “smart collagen” cream.

It’s true that Isagenix beauty and skin care products are designed to improve the appearance of your skin by moisturizing, cleansing, and protecting it from the sun – but they offer a different range of products that you may find expensive.

With XYZ smart collagen, that’s not the case.

Furthermore, it improves your skin’s natural production of collagen, which results in wrinkles and sagging as we age. The active ingredient in this beauty formula is derived from the leaf sap of Bulbine frutescens, a native plant of South Africa.

Scientific studies have shown that this sap contains two powerful compounds that slow collagen breakdown in the dermis and increase collagen production – without triggering the body’s immune system, which would interfere with the process and cause low-quality collagen to build up in the body.

Other benefits of this Isagenix beauty alternative include:

  • Improves skin texture
  • Reduces stretch marks
  • Reduces wrinkles
  • Lifts & contours
  • Tightens & firms

The cost of XYZ collagen goes to $49.9 for a pack. If you buy more than 1 pack, you get 1 pack for free. Plus, a free delivery.

#5. Herbalife


Herbalife is a meal replacement supplement with high protein content.

This product is full of healthy minerals and vitamins that boost your overall immunity and help you achieve your dream physique.

The protein present in Herbalife is obtained from all-natural sources which makes it a healthy product.

Herbalife VS Isagenix

Previously, protein supplements tasted like protein and dirt but today most protein supplements are available in numerous delicious flavors.

You can get Isagenix products in 6 different flavors but Herbalife takes the lead by offering 12 irresistible product flavors.

Herbalife is made of simple and effective ingredients such as vitamins, minerals, and protein. However, Isagenix contains 23 different nutrients along with a healthy carbohydrate and beneficial fat content.

Unlike Herbalife, Isagenix also contains a gluten-free and soy-free formula.

When it comes to the sugar content, Herbalife contains 9 grams of sugar per serving whereas Isagenix contains 11 grams of sugar per serving.

Therefore, it’s safe to say that Herbalife is among the healthier and better alternatives to Isagenix.

You can purchase a standard 750mg pack of Herbalife for $43.3. Whereas, 854 grams of Isagenix can be bought for $55.99 per canister and $59.99 per packet.

This means that Herbalife is a cheap alternative to Isagenix by a minor margin.

read more on Isagenix vs Herbalife here

#6. Exante Diet


Exante Diet is a brand that consists of various inventive meal replacement supplements.

Unlike most protein supplement brands, Exante Diet does not limit its product range to protein shakes, it contains a wide range of products consisting of meal replacement shakes, bars, and juices.

Exante Diet VS Isagenix

Isagenix products are famous for their nutrient-dense formula containing 23 important nutrients, protein, carbs, and essential fats.

However, the ingredient list of the Exante Diet takes the lead since it contains 27 essential nutrients along with multiple vitamins such as Vitamin B6, B12, B9, and Vitamin K.

The protein content of these supplements is extremely important as well.

Exante Diet contains 17 grams of protein per serving while Isagenix offers 24 grams of protein per serving.

Furthermore, Isagenix products are available in around 6 different flavors while Exante Diet has an enormous range of 33 different flavors.

Exante Diet products are available in the form of protein shakes, bars, and juices just like Isagenix products. Moreover, Exante Diet products are available in pounds and their usual price is within the range of 20 pounds. Isagenix products range between $55.99 to $59.99.

Therefore, Exante Diet costs less than Isagenix.

#7. 310 Shake

310 shake

310 Shake – another worthy Isagenix alternative. By 310 nutrition.

The 310 nutrition brand offers a wide range of protein-rich meal replacement shakes in the form of 310 shakes.

These shakes also contain a low carb content but their high concentration of protein increases your satiety levels and boosts your metabolism to promote effective weight management.

310 Shakes VS Isagenix

310 Shakes have more flavor options as compared to Isagenix since Isagenix offers 6 flavor options and 310 Shakes are available in 9 different flavors.

Isagenix products also contain a higher sugar content than the 310 shakes that get their sugar from all-natural sources.

Therefore, the sugar in 310 Shakes offers zero calories.

Both these products have a gluten-free formula that would help people with gluten intolerance.

However, Isagenix has a more beneficial ingredient list since it offers an assortment of 23 different nutrients. 310 Shakes contain prebiotics, probiotics, antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals but the Isagenix ingredient list is still superior.

There are 15 grams of protein in every serving for 310 shakes while Isagenix offers 24 grams of protein per serving.

You can purchase 854 grams of Isagenix products for $55.99 whereas you can get 775 grams of 310 Shakes for $39.

Therefore, 310 Shakes are a cheaper Isagenix shake alternative.

#8. Huel


Huel is another meal replacement supplement brand that offers protein-rich products.

It consists of a wide range of protein bars, shakes, and hot meals.

Huel VS Isagenix

Huel offers a more extensive ingredient list as compared to Isagenix since it contains 27 beneficial nutrients in addition to protein while Isagenix offers 23 nutrients.

Moreover, the protein powder comes in two forms that are Huel 3.0 and Huel Black edition. The Huel 3.0 powder has 9 flavors and Huel Black Edition comes in 6 flavors while Isagenix comes in 6 flavors.

Huel 3.0 offers 20 grams of protein per serving and Huel Black Edition contains 40 grams of protein per serving. However, Isagenix takes the lead with 24 grams of protein per serving.

When it comes to the sugar content, Huel 3.0 has less than 1% sugar and the Huel Black Edition powder is sugar-free.

Therefore, Huel products are a healthier alternative as opposed to Isagenix products which contain 11 grams of sugar per serving.

Like Isagenix, Huel also contains energy drinks, protein bars, and protein shakes.

However, Huel offers nutrient-dense hot and savory meals as well which aren’t offered by Isagenix.

You can get 2 bags of the Huel 3.0 powder with nearly 1700 grams of product at the cost of $65 and you can get 2 bags of the Huel Black Edition powder containing approximately 1700 grams of the product for $75. 854 grams of the Isagenix product are available for $55.99.

Therefore, Huel products are more budget-friendly.

#9. SlimFast


SlimFast is more than just a simple protein-rich meal replacement supplement brand.

It contains several beneficial ingredients that cater to different health issues. This brand also offers a wide range of nutritious products in the form of energy drinks, protein bars, and shakes.

SlimFast VS Isagenix

SlimFast is an inclusive brand that offers a wide range of products that cater to the needs of various people.

It has a line of low-carb content so that people following the keto diet can consume these products as well. And comes with energy-boosting products to help people with reduced energy levels.

Their diabetic range is the real winner though since it’s challenging for diabetics to come across healthy weight loss supplements.

Isagenix does not offer such a range of products.

However, both these supplements contain an impressive ingredient list with 23 different nutrients. SlimFast does not contain any type of processed sugars while Isagenix contains 11 grams of processed sugar per serving.

A 12.83oz bottle of SlimFast with 360 grams of product costs $9.99 while their 20.18oz canister with 557 grams of product costs $12.99.

You could also go for their three-pack 12.93oz canister with 366 grams of product for $26.97 or their three-pack 20.18oz bottle with 577 grams of product for $35.97.

A bottle of Isagenix with 854 grams of product costs $55.99. Therefore, SlimFast is a cheaper Isagenix alternative.

#10. Soylent


Soylent products are a rich source of high-quality soy protein that provides all sorts of essential amino acids.

Soylent VS Isagenix

Isagenix products contain 23 different nutrients while Soylent products consist of 28 different nutrients; therefore, Soylent has a better formula than Isagenix.

Soylent products also contain beneficial fats such as omega-3 fatty acids and omega-6 fatty acids that help with optimal hormone production.

Soylent products are made using a natural sugar called allulose that has almost zero calories while Isagenix contains 11 grams of processed sugar.

Soylent also contains a dairy-free formula.

A pack of 12 Soylent drinks costs $42 while 854 grams of Isagenix costs $55.99. Therefore, Soylent is more cost-effective.

#11. Optavia


Optavia is a brand that is focused on improving your overall health.

It contains a wide range of nutrient-dense snacks, shakes, and protein bars that help you achieve your ideal fitness goals.

Optavia VS Isagenix

Optavia products contain 14 grams of protein per serving while Isagenix products offer 24 grams of protein per serving. Optavia has an impressive ingredient list with vitamins such as Vitamin A, and Vitamin C, and minerals like calcium and iron.

However, Isagenix has a better ingredient list with 23 different nutrients.

Isagenix offers 11 grams of synthetic sugars per serving.

However, Optavia contains natural sugars in the form of honey and it has 10% sugar per serving.

Therefore, Optavia is a healthier Isagenix alternative.

Optavia also offers a healthier solution to Isagenix snack alternatives with its nutrient-dense snacks in the form of multi-flavored popcorn.

Unlike Isagenix, Optavia also offers cost-effective hot meals such as beef stew and chicken cacciatore.

However, it’s safe to say that Isagenix products are more cost-effective as compared to Optavia products since 854 grams of Isagenix products can be bought for $55.95, whereas Optavia offers 280 grams of products for $19.95.

Therefore, there is a slight difference in the price range but Optavia costs more than Isagenix.

Conclusion on the Best Isagenix Alternatives

Isagenix is a popular choice for a protein-rich meal replacement supplement.

However, there are numerous supplements out there and in case you were wondering what brands are comparable to Isagenix, you can go through all the high-protein, meal replacement products listed above.

All the products mentioned on the list except for Optavia are cheaper alternatives to Isagenix and they have a lower sugar content as well.

These healthier and cost-effective alternatives to Isagenix can be found in the United States, Canada, the UK, Australia, New Zealand, and all across the world.

All of the options on this list are great. However, if you ask me my preferred and most recommended option, I’d go for PhenQ meal shakes.

Important Disclaimer: The information contained on MAX HEALTH LIVING is intended for informational and educational purposes only. Any statements made on this website have not been evaluated by the FDA and any information or products discussed are not intended to diagnose, cure, treat, or prevent any disease or illness. Please consult a healthcare practitioner before making changes to your diet or taking supplements that may interfere with medications.

Who We Are

We are a team of fitness, health, and supplement experts, and content creators. Over the past 4 years, we have spent over 123,000 hours researching food supplements, meal shakes, weight loss, and healthy living. Our aim is to educate people about their effects, benefits, and how to achieve a maximum healthy lifestyle. Read more.