Herbalife vs Isagenix: Which is the Best? (compensation plan & health)

January 7, 2024 |

Posted By

Max Health Living is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

Nowadays, the world is full of many different meal replacement and protein shake products.

Two such companies are Herbalife and Isagenix.

What makes these two different?

As the name indicates, I am going to elaborately discuss two renowned health and fitness brands, Isagenix and Herbalife, in this article today.

When it comes to hectic weight loss journeys and struggles with your health at stake, it is important to go for the best fitness products out there that guarantee results without causing harm.

The odds are that you have agreed on trying out effective and quick fixes for weight loss like Herbalife and Isagenix.

Undoubtedly they are two popular and trusted dietary supplement manufacturing companies with a variety of products that offer solutions to your fitness and weight loss concerns.

The point is, what makes one of them better than the other?

I mean, obviously, you cannot opt for two weight loss programs at once.

Therefore you need to narrow it down more and then go for the best one – which is why, from benefits, downfalls, and side effects to customer feedback, I have explained what Herbalife and Isagenix have to offer to you.

So let’s dig in.

Herbalife and Isagenix – Overview

What is Herbalife?

Herbalife has been serving fitness enthusiasts all over the world for the past four decades.

It understands that opting for ways to achieve a good state of health and wellness can be bland at times, which is why it ensures that your fitness goals are exciting and fun to achieve.

How so?

You might ask.

By offering a diverse array of mouth-wateringly tasty nutritional supplements that you can use in your daily life, including meal replacement protein shakes, aloe vera derivatives, teas, healthy snacks, that too, without any unwanted hassle!

Another great feature that I like is how the company also offers to provide customized plans and solutions to each individual to assist him with his fitness journey.

You can share your concerns and areas where you want improvement, and the brand’s team will do the rest of the work for you!

In a nutshell, if you are one looking for quick and irresistibly yummy weight loss plans (unlike the conventional boring diets) without having to compromise much on your daily life, you should check out Herbalife.

With thousands of satisfied customers worldwide, the company has truly outdone itself.

What is Isagenix?

Isagenix logo

The second company that I am going to brief you about is Isagenix – another leading tycoon in the health and wellness industry.

Isagenix primarily focuses on providing you with the best to achieve an optimal state of health.

Not to mention that providing the customers with the best healthcare products, including shakes, nutritional supplements, snacks, skincare products, and a lot more, to help them become a better version of themselves is the brand’s motto.

You will come across an assortment of different products that may help you in your fitness quest.

Not only these but you are also offered certain weight loss programs like the 30-day challenge or the 9-day challenge to follow if you want to lose some pounds, that too quite quickly!

Even though the brand comes under the category of health and fitness companies that help in escalating your weight loss journey but it is much more than just a quick fix since years of thorough research and effort are put into the formulas to provide you with long-term benefits.

One thing that I liked is the categorization of the brand’s products not only according to the kind of food but also how and why you would like to incorporate it into your diet.

And once you go through the nutrient breakdown of their products, I bet you’ll not want to step back from getting your hands on those healthful ingredients – all in one pack.

Intrigued enough?

Jump on to my next section to find out how and why exactly are these two brands people’s favorite and what possible pros and cons you might encounter whilst use them.

Herbalife vs Isagenix – Weight Loss

Since meal replacement protein shakes for weight loss are the highlight of the article today, I am going to review them in detail here.

1. Benefits

Herbalife: The shakes comprise soy protein, vitamins, and minerals. The prime purpose of such a power-packed formula is to keep the consumer full with the required nutrition so that he does not feel the need to eat junk.

Also, the decreased appetite and increased energy levels help you stay fresh all day long.

Therefore when you ultimately do not go over the daily calorie requirement by consuming these low sugar shakes, you will end up losing those extra pounds.

Another distinct feature of the products is how all the shakes are free of both fat and cholesterol, which are fattening elements.

Isagenix: Comprising all the essential nutrients like whey protein, vitamins, and minerals, it is a quick fix if you cannot go for extensive, bland diets.

The products come in different flavors, so you’ll not find any limitation in that regard either.

Not only does it help to reduce appetite, but it also assists in the development of lean muscles, giving you the toned body that you might have always wanted.

A high quantity of proteins makes sure that you feel satiated and full of energy for most of the day, which ensures a lesser desire to binge-eat at odd times.

The Isagenix shakes are convenient to consume, too, so added effort is required. They can be delivered to your doorstep, which is another plus point given the busy schedules that all of us have these days.

Final Verdict: As we can see, both the brands work on the same principle of curbing the consumer’s hunger by incorporating a decent amount of protein in the shakes.

Moreover, additional nutrients are also added by both to provide extra health benefits.

So, I would call it a tie, as both the companies, can be seen outdoing themselves here.

2. Ingredients

Herbalife: Ingredients are an important factor to consider before consuming a product. You need to scan all the constituents carefully and identify if they suit you.

Herbalife’s protein shakes comprise soy protein, essential vitamins, riboflavin, and lots of fiber.

I have already mentioned that the shakes help you reduce weight by decreasing your appetite.

This is possible by the protein content present in it, which is further supplemented by fiber existing in the formula.

Now here, soy protein is a piece of good news for people with animals allergies who are not able to consume animal products.

Moreover, vitamins help you stay energetic, and riboflavin enhances new cell growth. This makes the product an all-rounder for your health concerns.

Isagenix: The key elements in Isagenix shakes include lots of whey protein.

This goes without saying since proteins are an integral part of our nutrition and play a key role in satiating hunger.

It is immediately taken up by the body, which is why the shake acts quicker as compared to that of Herbalife.

Other ingredients include metal ions like chromium. This must sound odd but let me tell you that chromium supplements the function of proteins in keeping our hunger pangs at bay.

This eventually results in lowered appetite and reduced calorie intake. Moreover,  active enzymes present in the products help your digestive system.

Fibre and vitamins are present to make the shake a complete meal since you get that extra energy even if you are not consuming a lot of calories.

Lastly, the presence of fructose makes the shake naturally sweet and delicious.

Final Verdict: It is always advised to look for key ingredients in a product.

Both Herbalife and Isagenix are rich in contents, latter more than former, that help in weight loss but have some downsides too. (discussed in detail in the next section)

3. Side Effects and Downfalls

Herbalife: There are no significant side effects reported following the use of Herbalife shakes and snacks.

However, if you are pregnant, a lactating mother, or suffer from any underlying medical condition (liver problem or kidney impairment), it is always advised to consult with your physician before consuming any product.

Also, please note that all the products, even though they help you with getting desired nutrients, are not ideal substitutes for healthy food.

Isagenix: Almost all the ingredients in Isagenix shakes are safe to consume and cause no considerable adverse effects.

The shakes, however, do contain a substantial amount of fructose which might pose problems for diabetics. People with underlying renal and liver disorders are also advised to consult their physician first.

But for diabetics, even I would not recommend Isagenix’s shakes.

Final Verdict: All in all, it would be correct to conclude that Diabetics can go for Herbalife instead of Isagenix because of the relatively low sugar levels and protein in the former’s shakes.

However, if you are perfectly alright, Isagenix shakes have the upper hand in being nutritious, so I would recommend you to go for them in that case.

4. Cost of Isagenix vs Herbalife

Herbalife: Herbalife shakes are relatively affordable if we keep in mind how nutritious and efficacious they are

They would cost you almost one and a half dollars per servings – great for people who want to start their fitness journey on a minimal budget.

One 750g container of Herbalife Formula 1 shake would cost you something between $37-$43.

Isagenix: On the other hand, the shakes by Isagenix are pretty expensive if compared to other brands in the market. It retails for about $55-$68 on Amazon.

Final Verdict: While Isagenix shakes have great nutritional value, the price is quite high and is not affordable for everyone.

Herbalife, being the cheaper alternative, has an advantage in this regard.

So, if you’re on a budget right now, Herbalife would make a worthy option.

5. Customer Feedback

Herbalife: when it comes to how Herbalife’s customers have been responding to the effects of their products, 90% of the results are positive!

However, some consumers stated that the protein content is not enough for it to be a ‘meal replacing’ shake and that they have to consume a snack or two to curb their hunger.

This might be true since the shakes do not have much protein and calories in them.

But others appreciated how the sugar content is low as compared to other meal replacement shakes, which is suitable for people at risk of developing diabetes.

The products might not be significantly fulfilling, but they sure do help in decreasing appetite to some extent. So, all in all, people can be seen overall happy about the results!

Isagenix: Customers have been all praises for Isagenix because of its formula loaded with nutrients, especially whey protein, which plays a key role in satiating hunger and thus fulfills the whole purpose of opting for a meal replacement shake.

A 28-year-old guy’s review caught my attention when he explained how the shakes made him feel more revitalized and energetic all day long, despite his tiring routine.

This actually sounds promising, especially if you’re also a heavy-duty worker who wants to get rid of unwanted fats too.

However, because of the high protein content, the consumers reported that they had to work out too to make use of all the protein.

But that’s not something to be considered as a downside since once you decide to lose weight, regular exercise should automatically become a part of your regimen.

Otherwise, instead of having to lose weight, you’ll end up storing all the protein as more fat in your body.

Final Verdict: Both the meal replacement giants have mixed reviews about their products. For some, the product did wonders; for others, the results didn’t come out as expected.

So, it basically depends on how and what you want because those who followed a healthy lifestyle and used the weight loss products described how they achieved their fitness goals in no time.

And considering that, I would give both the companies a big thumbs up!

FAQs on Herbalife and Isagenix

Is Isagenix better than Herbalife?

If you want a nutritious formula that is a meal replacement, then yes, Isagenix is better than Herbalife.

It has more protein, vitamin, and mineral content than Herbalife shakes, which makes it a high-calorie serving too.

However, if you are allergic to animal products or do not work out much, Herbalife might be the better option for you since it is lighter than Isagenix and comprises soy protein instead of whey protein.

What is the Isagenix 30 day challenge?

Isagenix’s 30-day challenge is all about losing weight in 30 days. It comprises shake days and cleanses days.

On shake days, you have to consume 2 Isagenix shakes instead of 2 meals and eat one healthy meal comprising 400-600 calories.

On cleanse days, you have to eat 4 Isagenix snack servings with 6 servings of Isagenix Cleanse for life liquid.

Cleanse days are encouraged once or twice a week and are considered as “intermittent fasting”.

The company claims that by following this schedule for 30 days and you will notice weight loss because of calorie restriction and portion control.

Does Isagenix make you gassy?

Symptoms like diarrhea or being gassy either occur as side effects of the shakes or if you are lactose intolerant.

Even though minor quantities of lactose are present in the formula, it still might trigger some people to become gassy.

One way to avoid that is to start consuming the product in smaller servings and then move on to larger ones.

Why do you have to drink Isagenix shakes within 10 minutes?

It is recommended to drink Isagenix shakes within 10 minutes since it comprises active enzymes which break down the principal component of the product; whey protein.

Active enzymes are added to help you with fast digestion by breaking down food actively. If kept longer, it starts breaking down the whey protein in the shake.

Does Isagenix taste good?

Isagenix shakes taste good because of the fructose present in them. Consumers state that the taste profile of all the products, especially the shakes was pretty good since the shakes are sweet and creamy even though no artificial sweeteners are added.

Which is the best Isagenix product for weight loss?

The best Isagenix product for weight loss is the Isalean shake which comes in a variety of flavors.

It comprises a lot of protein and essential nutrients that work by lowering your appetite and toning your muscles, thereby reducing excess calories intake. This eventually results in weight loss.

Herbalife vs Isagenix – Which one’s Best?

The debate between Herbalife and Isagenix is as old as time.

They’ve been around for decades, each with their own set of loyal followers who swear by them.

If you want to know which one will work best for your goals, we recommend taking a look at the ingredients in both products before making a decision.

Now that you have all the necessary information to compare the two meal replacement shakes, it will be easier to make the correct choice.

Let me be straight and honest! The decision of going for the best one out of the two is subjective. If you are looking for a meal replacement option that curbs your hunger while you are habitual of a good daily workout session, Isagenix is the best deal for you!

But if you cannot engage in physical activity and want a lighter substitute with fewer amount of proteins and fibers than too on a budget, Herbalife will be the ideal choice for you.

In the end, your fitness goals and priorities in diet matter the most in making the best decision.

I hope this article clarifies your ambiguities and will help you in going for the right product.

Important Disclaimer: The information contained on MAX HEALTH LIVING is intended for informational and educational purposes only. Any statements made on this website have not been evaluated by the FDA and any information or products discussed are not intended to diagnose, cure, treat, or prevent any disease or illness. Please consult a healthcare practitioner before making changes to your diet or taking supplements that may interfere with medications.

Who We Are

We are a team of fitness, health, and supplement experts, and content creators. Over the past 4 years, we have spent over 123,000 hours researching food supplements, meal shakes, weight loss, and healthy living. Our aim is to educate people about their effects, benefits, and how to achieve a maximum healthy lifestyle. Read more.