Herbalife vs Juice Plus: Which is Better?

January 8, 2024 |

Posted By

Max Health Living is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

In this article, I’m going to compare Herbalife and Juice Plus’s meal replacement options elaborately.

Now that you have stumbled upon this article, it is evident that you’re confused as to which one of the two meal replacement supplements to go for and how to weigh the pros and cons of both.

Where one is renowned for its effective aid in weight loss and a diverse range to choose from, the other is a substitute of fresh farm produce, providing you with the supplementary nutrition you need.

And when the competition is this tough, it becomes daunting to pick out one.

But no worries, I have this sorted out for you.

With a detailed comparison of the products with their ingredients, taste, cost, and other details, it is going to be super convenient for you to decide which one to go for.

So let’s dig in!

Herbalife vs Juice Plus – A Brief Rundown

Before getting into the detailed comparisons of what both the companies have to offer, let us have a quick overview of their respective origins and motives.

1. Herbalife

Renowned for its miraculous weight loss protein meal replacement shakes, Herbalife has been proving to be one of the best health and fitness brands for the last four decades.

The company has a diverse product range comprising weight loss shakes, customized diet plans, nutritional supplements, and various other health care and beauty products.

The main aim of the brand is to provide the best to its customers so that they do not have to compromise on their health and fitness.

With delicious nutritional snacks and shakes, Herbalife ensures that you and your taste buds are both content and happy.

Herbalife was found in Los Angeles and has made its way to almost 90 countries to date.

The secret behind its success is the budget and user-friendly products/diet plans that people from almost all age groups can conveniently use.

So, if you are looking for a relatively affordable yet healthfully beneficial option to assist you in your weight loss journey, Herbalife might be an excellent choice!

2. Juice Plus

Juice plus

The second renowned brand in the world of weight loss aids that I am going to discuss is Juice Plus.

Efficient and healthy weight loss has now become easier now that reputable companies like Juice plus have entered the picture.

We are aware of how hectic and jam-packed routines do not allow us to prepare special meals dedicated to our individual weight loss goals. In such a situation, the journey towards efficacious weight loss becomes next to impossible.

But fret not! Juice Plus is here to ensure that those gaps are filled with something nutritious so that you are not deprived of the essential nutrients during your weight loss journey since it has literal quick fixes to offer!

The brand claims the supplements to be a substitute for fruits and vegetables, so you can consume these in between meals or as a replacement for one or two meals to make the most out of them, especially when there is no time to snack!

Different variants are available in the supplements by the brand, which may help you satisfy your taste buds and make your weight loss journey interesting and worthwhile.

Herbalife and Juice Plus – Which One Is Better?

1. Benefits/Efficacy

Herbalife: The products, especially the meal replacement shakes offered by the brand, ensure that you feel fuller so that there is no need to binge eat at odd times and thus put on unwanted calories – the first step to effective weight loss.

This is mainly executed by proteins present in the products.

The nutritious formulas of Herbalife may help you to achieve your daily dose of nutrition along with keeping your calorie intake in check.

Its nutrient-rich products may not only help boost your metabolism for quicker digestion but also prevent fat build-up since they are devoid of unhealthy fat and cholesterol – notorious fattening elements.

All in all, their shakes can give you the strength to build lean muscle mass while slowly helping you get rid of the extra pounds.

Juice Plus: According to NIH, dietary supplements are not exactly substituted for essential foods and nutrients, but they play a crucial role in making up for most of the nutrients that we do not get daily.

Juice Plus is one such example!

Packed with nutrients like folic acid, antioxidants, vitamins, omega 3 fatty acids, and some other useful concentrates from farm-fresh produce, Juice Plus can be your ideal dietary supplement that can help rejuvenate your muscles and metabolic processes.

The company does not claim to help you lose weight by the products entirely, so a healthy lifestyle along with these dietary supplements is important to see visible results.

Final Verdict: Both Herbalife and Juice Plus are remarkable dietary supplements packed with essential nutrients that serve the same purpose – providing you with the required energy and nutrients for a healthy lifestyle.

Which is why I would call this round a tie.

2. Side Effects

Herbalife: With numerous health benefits, certain side effects accompany the products of Herbalife. Even though the brand has proved to be efficacious in weight loss and general well-being, it is said to cause liver and renal toxicity.

Some people also reported nausea, general fatigue, vomiting, and abdominal discomfort. Therefore, I would recommend that people with underlying conditions, especially liver disorders, are advised to consult a specialist first.

Juice Plus: Being an artificial alternative to farm produce, Juice Plus has its share of side effects and warnings that are informed to consumers.

It is not suitable for children and pregnant women because of the high quantity of caffeine present in the products. Some consumers have also complained of nausea and vomiting following the consumption of the bars and snacks.

And similar to Herbalife, it is also not suitable for people with underlying medical conditions like liver and renal issues, so don’t forget to get an expert’s advice beforehand.

Final Verdict: All the products from both brands have their fair share of adverse effects because let’s get this straight – none of these are comparable to Wholefoods and natural farm-fresh products.

However, in my opinion, Juice Plus has lesser side effects than Herbalife. But again, it is still advised to consult an expert before incorporating any dietary supplements into your diet to achieve your fitness goals.

3. Juice Plus vs Herbalife – Cost

Herbalife: The price of Herbalife products ranges from the least $30 to as high as $150.

They are also available in complete packages, which may save you some extra pennies.

However, if I talk about the shakes in particular here, Herbalife’s 26.4 oz Formula 1 shake will cost you around 40 bucks (per pack).

Juice Plus:  Juice Plus is comparatively more pricey than Herbalife as its 20.1 oz shake will cost you around 70 bucks, which is (almost) double the price of Herbalife’s shakes.

Final Verdict: When it comes to the cost and pricing of the products, Herbalife will take the lead as it would cost you lesser for more products, which goes the other way around if we talk about juice plus.

4. Taste

Herbalife: The protein meal replacement shakes as well as the supplements give off a ‘synthetic’ taste.

Some people have found it to be powdery in texture even after mixing it with water or skimmed milk.

However, the good part about its taste is that it is not overly sweet, which is a plus point for diabetics since similar products are way too sweet because of added preservatives and artificial sweeteners.

Juice Plus: The shakes and supplements have a sweeter taste when compared to those of Herbalife.

But, rest assured the sugar in it is derived from grape and sugar beet, which confirms that no artificial sweeteners have made it to the product.

A big win-win!

Final Verdict: If you are a diabetic or at risk of developing diabetes, you would want to go for Herbalife since it has lesser sugar content.

On the other hand, if you are okay with consuming sugar particularly sucrose derived from natural fruits and vegetables, Juice Plus can make a viable option for you.

5. Product Range

Herbalife: The products offered by Herbalife include meal replacement protein shakes, aloe drinks, bars, teas, vitamins, and other skincare/beauty products.

From products that can be consumed orally and applied topically, Herbalife has it all.

You also get a wide range of flavors in its meal replacement shakes and supplements.

Juice Plus: The company offers the goodness of 30 fruits and vegetables in chewable or capsule forms.

You can get the fruit (orchard blend), vegetable (garden blend), and Berry (vineyard blend), respectively.

Juice Plus also offers soups, bars, and snacks in addition to supplements.

They also have this supplementary diet called Juice Plus Complete which, as the name indicates, is part of a proper diet regimen that is to be followed along with a healthy lifestyle and exercise for weight loss.

Final Verdict: Herbalife wins in this category because of the diversity it exhibits in its products as compared to Juice Plus, which is restricted to a few shakes and supplements.

6. Ingredients

Herbalife: The brand is a blend of efficacious ingredients, including a good amount of protein, fiber, vitamins, and minerals. This power-packed formula deems it best as a meal replacement option.

Proteins in the products make sure that your satiety hormones are activated, which eventually means suppression of hunger hormones.

This results in decreased appetite and lowered cravings for junk food, ultimately leading to weight loss.

The fiber in the formula is responsible for slowing down digestion. This may come off as a surprise but trust me, it happens for good!

Slowed-down digestion means less time for fat to get stored in tissues which might otherwise lead to obesity.

Essential vitamins that act as antioxidants help fight off unstable free radicals that harm your body in various ways.

Minerals and ions in it may help with healthy metabolic functions in your body.

Juice Plus: Coming to the ingredients that Juice Plus comprises – it is jam-packed with the goodness of fruits, vegetables, and grains!

It is a condensed powder that is derived from fruits and vegetable extracts which means it is full of essential nutrients like vitamins and minerals.

Antioxidants like Vitamin C and E, as well as carotene, help protect you from damage against unstable particles called free radicals.

This gives you the required rejuvenation of muscle tissue and increased energy levels.

Folic acid, enzymes, and probiotics are other important constituents that help the body’s natural flora to flourish, which eventually means healthier functioning of the body.

It comprises small amounts of fiber, so is not an absolute weight loss aid, but with apt healthy lifestyle choices and these nutritious supplements, you can achieve your weight loss goals with it.

Final Verdict: Both brands have important constituents that can help in weight loss in one way or another.

The exact quantity of ingredients is not mentioned in both of these, which is a downfall of both brands.

But, all in all, I find Juice Plus to be slightly better than Herbalife as the ingredients are somewhat derived from natural plants and have lesser preservatives.

7. Juice Plus and Herbalife Business Opportunity

Herbalife: Being a seller, too, you can benefit from the company as an independent distributor since Herbalife exclusively compensates its distributors based on the number of sales.

To become a preferred Herbalife distributor, you will have to spend just $34.95 USD upfront, once and for all.

Juice Plus: Juice Plus also offers compensation for its independent distributors by paying a margin of profit for each sale they make.

To become a part of the Juice Plus team, you’ll have to fill out and submit a simple form and pay a one-time membership fee of $50.

Final Verdict: It simply depends on your exposure and your marketing skills and how much you’re able to make being a product distributor.

So, no matter which team you join, if you’re not the kind of person who can step out and persuade people into buying and trying some new products, this scheme might not make a suitable option for you.

However, if you think you have got what it takes, then Herbalife would be a cheaper option to get started with, as compared to juice plus.

Everything Else You Need To Know – FAQs

Why Juice Plus is not good for you?

While Juice Plus offers a wide variety of products with distinct flavors which makes the weight loss journey quite enjoyable, it has its fair share of cons.

So dietary supplements like Juice Plus and others are not preferred over natural nutrition as they may induce liver and renal disorders as well as general discomfort.

Are Juice Plus shakes good for weight loss?

Juice Plus shakes and supplements do not cause weight loss entirely on their own as they are only ‘aids’ to healthy nutrition and lifestyle which may, in turn, help you lose weight.

Therefore, the only way juice plus can prove to be good for weight loss is to supplement it with healthy life choices like regular exercise and a balanced diet.

Is Juice Plus better than Herbalife?

In terms of flavor and overall nutrition profile, Juice Plus is better than Herbalife as it contains nutrients like folic acid, carotene, and antioxidants in addition to proteins and vitamins.

All of these together form a dynamic product that can help you in a lot of ways.

Herbalife, on the other hand, has a greater variety when it comes to product range and diversity whereas Juice Plus has fewer options for you.

Is Juice Plus really worth the money?

If you are a victim of hectic routines with no time to make fresh smoothies and shakes, Juice Plus might be something worth spending your money on.

It provides fruit and vegetable extracts with almost all the desired nutrients in it which you otherwise skip in your daily routine so it is worth buying.

Do doctors recommend Juice Plus?

Doctors recommend Juice Plus shakes and snacks as supplements to add to your daily calorie intake since the usual stuff we eat is not sufficient for a healthy body and lifestyle so they act as a bridge between the required and the actual nutrition.

Replacing essential meals with these supplements is not advised by doctors. People already suffering from liver and renal disorders are also advised to stay away from these dietary supplements.

Why Herbalife is bad for you?

Herbalife might be bad for some people since the excess protein and highly processed shakes are not suitable for people with underlying medical conditions like diabetes and liver disorders.

How many Juice Plus capsules do you take a day?

2 Juice Plus capsules are recommended to be taken every day. These can be engulfed with water during meal times. Remember to not go beyond 2 capsules a day.

How many Juice Plus shakes a day?

Like capsules, Juice Plus shakes are recommended to be used twice a day. These should be taken as supplementary shakes along with regular meals or as replacement shakes with only one major meal.

Does Juice Plus help hair growth?

No. There is nothing particular in the formula which can prove to be helpful for your hair growth.

Final Thoughts

It gets quite confusing as to which product to go for since both brands offer a variety of pros as well as cons.

To help you make an informed decision, I discussed all the important features in the article.

In a nutshell, I would say that I find Juice Plus better than Herbalife. Even though Herbalife has a wide variety of products, Juice Plus wins the edge with its concentrated nutritious formulas that are enriched with fruit and vegetable goodness.

The brand does not make fake claims of entirely being responsible for weight loss and is honest about the efficacy of its products which makes it better than the former.

I hope this article makes it easy for you to pick out the best company, based on your preferences.

Important Disclaimer: The information contained on MAX HEALTH LIVING is intended for informational and educational purposes only. Any statements made on this website have not been evaluated by the FDA and any information or products discussed are not intended to diagnose, cure, treat, or prevent any disease or illness. Please consult a healthcare practitioner before making changes to your diet or taking supplements that may interfere with medications.

Who We Are

We are a team of fitness, health, and supplement experts, and content creators. Over the past 4 years, we have spent over 123,000 hours researching food supplements, meal shakes, weight loss, and healthy living. Our aim is to educate people about their effects, benefits, and how to achieve a maximum healthy lifestyle. Read more.